So while I'm working out here for a few weeks, I've been trying a lot of different places and I happen to find this place one of my first nights. Great little dive bar with an awesome bartender on a Thursday night. Fun crowd. And then you get to the sandwiches and the pizza. Anything that uses the meatballs is highly recommended. The bread is so good and the meatballs have this amazingly perfect texture and flavor. The price is also great. I also got the pizza to go for the next day because the sandwich was so good. I just had to try it. Even reheated the pizza was amazing and I highly recommend it. It had a chopped meatball sauce, which was just awesome.

Visited Missing Jimmy's for lunch today because of the Youngstown theme. Loved it! Got the Nicky Santoro sub and had to grab a white pizza, because when it's the real deal you can't not get it. Cool chat with the bartender and a back home feel. Recommended for sure!

Love this place. Came late night from out of town for a night cap. Great tunes and great guys behind the bar. Have never seen Malort outside of Chicago (except at burning man) but they got it here. Great end to an otherwise hectic travel day, thanks fellas

The first time I walked into Missing Jimmy's I felt like I was in my hometown of Youngstown, Ohio! It's wonderful to have a place in Columbus, Ohio that represents so well the Italian history in Youngstown. Rob and Vinnie and their staff have perfected the pizza, subs, and Meatball bowls! Everything I have had there has been incredible! The Meatball bowl with the pesto pasta salad is probably one of my favorite things. The combination of flavors is fantastic! The pizza brings back great memories of growing up in Youngstown!! The Atmosphere is fun, family, friendly with corn hole set up outside and TV and sports in the inside. The staff go above and beyond to make sure that your visit Missing Jimmy's will be the first of many! The bartenders serve up great drinks and beer along with their great food to make this the perfect date night or great place together with friends!! Try out Missing Jimmy's, you will not be disappointed !!

What a hidden gem! We came on a Saturday night to watch some Bball and thoroughly enjoyed the pizzas! Get the Big Fat Antnee!!! We even ordered one to take home. The Stand up guy pizza was also good!! I think I may have to work my way through the menu. The Meatball subs look Phenomenal!! Service was good. You order at the bar. Great place to watch sports and hang with friends. Cohort felt at home, he's from Youngstown area as well.

Awesome food Jimmy Hoffa theme! Youngstown Cbus hangout Good beer Good pizza and other food too Lots of tvs What else could one need??!

We came across Missing Jimmy's while walking around historic Dublin, but the shopping area they are located in does have its own parking lot. Fun place full of TVs showing sports, a foosball table, and some nice Christmas decor for the season. They serve up Meatball Mafia food, and it smelled great in there. We got the Nicky Santoro meatball subs to go. It was well packaged. The food was great - so flavorful, great kick from the hot giardiniera. Service was quick. We will definitely stop by again.

So, stop waiting until you lose ten pounds, until you gain ten pounds, until you have kids, until your kids leave the house, until you start work, until you retire, until you get married, until you get divorced, until Friday night, until Sunday morning, until you get a new car or home, until your car or home is paid off, until spring, until summer, until winter, until your song comes on, until you've had a drink.... there is no better time than right now to be happy.

If you are from NE Ohio you will love this place. If you like good food and a relaxed atmosphere you will love this place. You just need to find it. In Downtown Dublin walk south past DVT. You will get to a small parking lot. Missing Jimmy's is right there. Plenty of cold beer to choose from. Full bar besides that. Food options with some Youngstown connections (DeRusso's). The White pizza was thick and chewy just like I like it. The meatballs and ricotta were great and came with a slice of bread to soak up all that sauce. TVs are there but not obtrusive. Get there early as the place fills up quick!

This place has real Youngstown vibes. Pretty cool. I am excited to come back again and try all the food. I think they need to add wings to the menu though.